The murder of enemy soldiers by military personnel during combat operations: problems of qualification and exemption from criminal liability
Abstract and keywords
Abstract (English):
The problems of criminal legal assessment of military personnel's actions related to causing harm during hostilities, regulated by international law, are not fully implemented in the Russian legal system. In particular, there are no norms in Chapter 8 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation that exclude the criminality of an act related to the murder of enemy army soldiers during an armed conflict. The article substantiates the need to classify these actions as socially useful, and their inclusion in the list of circumstances excluding criminal liability.

Keywords:
military personnel, murder, fighting, crime, military violence, combatant
Text
Publication text (PDF): Read Download
References

1. Zverev, P. G. 2005, Legal status of legitimate participants in armed conflicts: PhD thesis (Law), Moscow.

2. Imangulova, G. R. 2014, ‘Some problems of determining the legal status of combatants’, Eurasian Law Journal, iss. 12(79), pp. 66-68.

3. Klauzevic, K. 2007, About the war, translated from German, Eksmo, Midgard, Moscow, St. Petersburg.

4. Ksenofontov, V. A. 2018, ‘Modern war: the main features’, Humanitarian problems of military affairs, iss. 1(14), pp. 65-72.

5. Kurnosova, T. I. 2016, Implementation of international legal norms on war crimes and crimes against humanity into Russian criminal legislation: PhD thesis (Law), Moscow.

6. Kurnosova, T. I. 2015, ‘The concept and ways of implementing the norms of international law into national legislation’, Actual problems of Russian law, iss. 4, pp. 203-207.

7. Lenin, V. I. 1962, Complete works, in 55 vols, vol. 30, Publishing House of Political Literature, Moscow.

8. Pavlova, L. A. 2007, ‘Types of armed conflicts and the status of participants in armed conflicts under international law’, International law, iss. 2, pp. 14-19.

9. Pchelkina, E. V. 2016, ‘Some problems of determining the legal status of combatants and non-combatants in the First and Second World War’, Successes of modern science, vol. 16, iss. 11, pp. 160-163.

10. Rozov, N. S. 2009, ‘The Nature of War: a Macrosociological analysis of the Essence and causes of mass organized Violence’, Humanitarian Vector, iss. 1, pp. 29-39.

11. Rozov, N. S. 2003, ‘War is Always Near: The Essence and Origin of Mass Organized Violence’, Time of Peace, iss. 3, pp. 75-120.

12. Korel'skij, V. M. & Perevalov, V. D. (eds) 1997, Theory of State and law, INFRA.M, Norm, Moscow.

13. Trockaja, A. V. 2016, ‘To the question of the essence of war’, Bulletin of Youth Science, iss. 1(3), p. 23.

14. Brilliantov, A. V. (ed.) 2018. Criminal Law of Russia, Parts General and Special: textbook, Prospectus, Moscow.

15. Chernyshev, D. B. & Karymova, K. R. 2022, ‘The legal basis for the exemption of military personnel from criminal liability for causing death to the enemy during hostilities’, Military law, iss. 4(74), pp. 223-228.

Login or Create
* Forgot password?